-lost to E 11 Marquette 55-66
| 2010 | Atlantic 10 | West | 6 |
beat W 11 Minnesota 65-54
+beat W 3 Pittsburgh 71-68
lost to W 2 Kansas St 96-101, 2 OT
| 2009 | Atlantic 10 | East | 4 |
beat E 13 Portland St 77-59
beat E 12 Wisconsin 60-49
lost to E 1 Pittsburgh 55-60
| 2008 | Atlantic 10 | West | 3 |
beat W 14 Georgia 73-61
beat W 6 Purdue 85-78
beat W 7 West Virginia 79-75, OT
lost to W 1 UCLA 57-76
| 2007 | Atlantic 10 | South | 9 |
+beat S 8 BYU 79-77
lost to S 1 Ohio State 71-78, OT
| 2006 | Atlantic 10 | West | 14 |
lost to W 3 Gonzaga 75-79
| 2004 | Atlantic 10 | South | 7 |
beat S 10 Louisville 80-70
+beat S 2 Mississippi St 89-74
+beat S 3 Texas 79-71
lost to S 1 Duke 63-66
| 2003 | Atlantic 10 | South | 3 |
beat S 14 Troy 71-59
-lost to S 6 Maryland 64-77
| 2002 | Atlantic 10 | West | 7 |
beat W 10 Hawaii 70-58
lost to W 2 Oklahoma 65-78
| 2001 | Atlantic 10 | Midwest | 11 |
lost to M 6 Notre Dame 71-83
| 1998 | Atlantic 10 | East | 6 |
-lost to E 11 Washington 68-69
| 1997 | Atlantic 10 | Midwest | 7 |
beat M 10 Vanderbilt 80-68
lost to M 2 UCLA 83-96
| 1995 | Horizon | Southeast | 11 |
lost to SE 6 Georgetown 63-68
| 1993 | Horizon | Midwest | 9 |
+beat M 8 New Orleans 73-55
lost to M 1 Indiana 70-73
| 1991 | Horizon | Midwest | 14 |
+beat M 3 Nebraska 89-84
lost to M 11 Connecticut 50-66
| 1990 | Horizon | Midwest | 6 |
beat M 11 Kansas St 87-79
+beat M 3 Georgetown 74-71
-lost to M 10 Texas 89-102
| 1989 | Horizon | Southeast | 14 |
lost to SE 3 Michigan 87-92
| 1988 | Horizon | Midwest | 11 |
lost to M 6 Kansas 72-85
| 1987 | Horizon | Midwest | 13 |
+beat M 4 Missouri 70-69
lost to M 5 Duke 60-65
| 1986 | Horizon | Southeast | 12 |
lost to SE 5 Alabama 80-97
| 1983 | Horizon | Midwest | |
lost to M 12 Alcorn St 75-81
| 1961 | Independent | Mideast | |
|
lost to Morehead St 66-71
| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |