-lost to S 12 Texas A&M 58-66
| 2005 | Big East | South | 4 |
-lost to S 13 Vermont 57-60, OT
| 2004 | Big East | West | 5 |
beat W 12 BYU 80-75
+beat W 4 Maryland 72-70
-lost to W 8 Alabama 71-80
| 2003 | Big East | East | 3 |
beat E 14 Manhattan 76-65
beat E 6 Oklahoma St 68-56
beat E 10 Auburn 79-78
+beat E 1 Oklahoma 63-47
+beat S 1 Texas 95-84
+beat W 2 Kansas 81-78
| 2001 | Big East | Midwest | 5 |
beat M 12 Hawaii 79-69
lost to M 4 Kansas 58-87
| 2000 | Big East | Midwest | 4 |
beat M 13 Samford 79-65
beat M 5 Kentucky 52-50
lost to M 1 Michigan St 58-75
| 1999 | Big East | South | 8 |
-lost to S 9 Oklahoma St 61-69
| 1998 | Big East | South | 5 |
beat S 12 Iona 63-61
+beat S 4 New Mexico 56-46
lost to S 1 Duke 67-80
| 1996 | Big East | West | 4 |
beat W 13 Montana St 88-55
beat W 12 Drexel 69-58
beat W 8 Georgia 83-81, OT
+beat W 2 Kansas 60-57
beat SE 5 Mississippi St 77-69
lost to M 1 Kentucky 67-76
| 1995 | Big East | Midwest | 7 |
beat M 10 Southern Ill 96-92
lost to M 2 Arkansas 94-96, OT
| 1994 | Big East | West | 4 |
beat W 13 Hawaii 92-78
beat W 12 Wis-Green Bay 64-59
lost to W 1 Missouri 88-98, OT
| 1992 | Big East | East | 6 |
beat E 11 Princeton 51-43
lost to E 3 Massachusetts 71-77, OT
| 1991 | Big East | East | 2 |
-lost to E 15 Richmond 69-73
| 1990 | Big East | Southeast | 2 |
beat SE 15 Coppin St 70-48
beat SE 7 Virginia 63-61
-lost to SE 6 Minnesota 75-82
| 1989 | Big East | Midwest | 2 |
beat M 15 Bucknell 104-81
beat M 10 Colorado St 65-50
beat M 3 Missouri 83-80
lost to M 1 Illinois 86-89
| 1988 | Big East | East | 3 |
beat E 14 North Carolina A&T 69-55
-lost to E 11 Rhode Island 94-97
| 1987 | Big East | East | 2 |
beat E 15 Georgia So 79-73
beat E 10 Western Ky 104-86
beat E 6 Florida 87-81
+beat E 1 North Carolina 79-75
beat SE 6 Providence 77-63
lost to M 1 Indiana 73-74
| 1986 | Big East | East | 2 |
beat E 15 Brown 101-52
-lost to E 7 Navy 85-97
| 1985 | Big East | East | 7 |
beat E 10 DePaul 70-65
lost to E 2 Georgia Tech 53-70
| 1984 | Big East | East | 3 |
beat E 6 VCU 78-63
-lost to E 7 Virginia 55-63
| 1983 | Big East | East | 6 |
beat E 11 Morehead St 74-59
lost to E 3 Ohio State 74-79
| 1980 | Big East | East | 1 |
beat E 8 Villanova 97-83
-lost to E 5 Iowa 77-88
| 1979 | Independent | East | 4 |
beat E 5 Connecticut 89-81
-lost to E 9 Pennsylvania 76-84
| 1978 | Independent | Mideast | |
lost to Western Ky 86-87, OT
| 1977 | Independent | Mideast | |
beat Tennessee 93-88, OT
lost to Charlotte 59-81
| 1976 | Independent | Midwest | |
lost to Texas Tech 56-69
| 1975 | Independent | East | |
beat La Salle 87-83, OT
beat North Carolina 78-76
beat Kansas St 95-87, OT
lost to Kentucky 79-95
lost to Louisville 88-96, OT
| 1974 | Independent | Midwest | |
lost to Oral Roberts 82-86, OT
| 1973 | Independent | East | |
beat Furman 83-82
lost to Maryland 75-91
beat Pennsylvania 69-68
| 1966 | Independent | East | |
beat Davidson 94-78
lost to Duke 81-91
| 1957 | Independent | East | |
|
beat Connecticut 82-76
beat Lafayette 75-74
lost to North Carolina 58-67
| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |