-lost to W 13 San Diego 69-70, OT
| 2006 | Big East | East | 1 |
beat E 16 Albany 72-59
beat E 8 Kentucky 87-83
beat E 5 Washington 98-92, OT
-lost to E 11 George Mason 84-86, OT
| 2005 | Big East | East | 2 |
beat E 15 UCF 77-71
-lost to E 10 North Carolina St 62-65
| 2004 | Big East | West | 2 |
beat W 15 Vermont 70-53
beat W 7 DePaul 72-55
beat W 6 Vanderbilt 73-53
beat W 8 Alabama 87-71
+beat S 1 Duke 79-78
beat M 3 Georgia Tech 82-73
| 2003 | Big East | South | 5 |
beat S 12 BYU 58-53
+beat S 4 Stanford 85-74
lost to S 1 Texas 78-82
| 2002 | Big East | East | 2 |
beat E 15 Hampton 78-67
beat E 7 North Carolina St 77-74
beat E 11 Southern Ill 71-59
lost to E 1 Maryland 82-90
| 2000 | Big East | South | 5 |
beat S 12 Utah St 75-67
lost to S 4 Tennessee 51-65
| 1999 | Big East | West | 1 |
beat W 16 TX-San Antonio 91-66
beat W 9 New Mexico 78-56
beat W 5 Iowa 78-68
beat W 10 Gonzaga 67-62
beat S 4 Ohio State 64-58
beat E 1 Duke 77-74
| 1998 | Big East | East | 2 |
beat E 15 Fairleigh Dickinson 93-85
beat E 7 Indiana 78-68
beat E 11 Washington 75-74
lost to E 1 North Carolina 64-75
| 1996 | Big East | Southeast | 1 |
beat SE 16 Colgate 68-59
beat SE 9 Eastern Mich 95-81
-lost to SE 5 Mississippi St 55-60
| 1995 | Big East | West | 2 |
beat W 15 Chattanooga 100-71
beat W 7 Cincinnati 96-91
beat W 3 Maryland 99-89
lost to W 1 UCLA 96-102
| 1994 | Big East | East | 2 |
beat E 15 Rider 64-46
beat E 10 George Wash 75-63
-lost to E 3 Florida 60-69, OT
| 1992 | Big East | Southeast | 9 |
+beat SE 8 Nebraska 86-65
lost to SE 1 Ohio State 55-78
| 1991 | Big East | Midwest | 11 |
+beat M 6 LSU 79-62
beat M 14 Xavier 66-50
lost to M 2 Duke 67-81
| 1990 | Big East | East | 1 |
beat E 16 Boston U 76-52
beat E 9 California 74-54
beat E 5 Clemson 71-70
-lost to E 3 Duke 78-79, OT
| 1979 | Independent | East | 5 |
lost to E 4 Syracuse 81-89
| 1976 | Yankee | East | |
beat Hofstra 80-78, OT
lost to Rutgers 79-93
| 1967 | Yankee | East | |
lost to Boston College 42-48
| 1965 | Yankee | East | |
lost to St. Joseph's 61-67
| 1964 | Yankee | East | |
beat Temple 53-48
beat Princeton 52-50
lost to Duke 54-101
| 1963 | Yankee | East | |
lost to West Virginia 71-77
| 1960 | Yankee | East | |
lost to New York 59-78
| 1959 | Yankee | East | |
lost to Boston U 58-60
| 1958 | Yankee | East | |
lost to Dartmouth 64-75
| 1957 | Yankee | East | |
lost to Syracuse 76-82
| 1956 | Yankee | East | |
beat Manhattan 84-75
lost to Temple 59-65
lost to Dartmouth 64-85
| 1954 | Yankee | East | |
lost to Navy 80-85
| 1951 | Yankee | East | |
|
lost to St. John's 52-63
| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |